Jewelry

Gold karats and nickel: is 10k, 14k or 18k safe for sensitive skin?

Gold has a reputation as the “safe” metal for sensitive ears, and pure gold almost never causes a reaction. But jewelry is rarely pure gold. It’s an alloy, and the other metals are where problems start.

Karat in plain numbers

Karat Gold content What else is in it
24k 99.9% Almost nothing; too soft for most jewelry
22k 91.7% Small amounts of silver, copper, zinc
18k 75% 25% other metals
14k 58.3% 41.7% other metals
10k 41.7% 58.3% other metals (the US legal minimum to be called “karat gold”)

The lower the karat, the more room there is for other metals, and the more chance one of them is nickel.

Color changes the recipe

  • Yellow gold is usually alloyed with silver, copper and zinc. Nickel is uncommon in yellow alloys, though not impossible.
  • White gold needs a “whitening” metal. Traditionally that was nickel; many jewelers now use palladium instead. The two look similar and are often both rhodium-plated, so you can’t tell by eye. Ask.
  • Rose gold gets its color from copper. Nickel isn’t a normal ingredient, but cheaper alloys vary.

Plated isn’t solid

“Gold-plated”, “gold electroplate” and “gold vermeil” (gold over sterling silver) carry a thin gold layer. “Gold-filled” has a thicker bonded layer. All of them sit on another metal that becomes exposed with wear. The FTC’s jewelry guides set the terms jewelers should use for these, so the wording on the tag tells you a lot.

What to ask

  1. Is it solid gold, and what karat?
  2. Is the alloy nickel-free? (For white gold: is it palladium white gold?)
  3. For earrings: are the post and backs the same alloy?

A jeweler who can’t answer the second question is telling you something too.

Not medical advice. This guide is general information, not a diagnosis or treatment plan. If you have a rash that spreads, blisters, swelling of the face or lips, trouble breathing or symptoms in a baby, get medical care. A board-certified dermatologist or allergist can confirm what you react to with patch or allergy testing. Medical disclaimer

Sources we checked

  1. U.S. FTC: Guides for the jewelry, precious metals, and pewter industries
  2. DermNet: Nickel allergy

Links point to the original publisher. We re-check sources when we update a page; if one has moved or changed, tell us.